Recruitment Fee Agreements: 5 Clauses Founders Should Negotiate in January 2026
Dover
January 26, 2026
•
4 mins
Most tech employment agencies charge 15-25% of first-year salary as their placement fee. For executive roles, fees reach 20-30%. When you're hiring a software engineer at $150,000, that's $22,500 to $37,500 per hire.
For early-stage companies, these costs add up fast. Hire three senior engineers and two product managers in a quarter, and you're looking at $150,000+ in agency fees. That's runway you could spend on product development or an additional headcount.
Here's what many founders miss: these fees are negotiable. Agencies build markup into their standard rates, expecting pushback. The percentage you pay is a starting point for discussion, not a fixed cost.
Agencies charging the highest fees aren't necessarily delivering better candidates, and choosing the right type of recruiter matters more than price alone. They're just better at pricing. When you walk into contract negotiations knowing these baseline numbers, you're already ahead.
Exclusivity clauses give agencies sole rights to fill a role for a set period. During this window, you can't work with other recruiters or post the job publicly, even if the agency isn't delivering candidates.
Typical exclusive agreements last 30 days, but some agencies push for 60 or 90. If your recruiter isn't performing, you're stuck waiting while your hiring timeline slips.
When reviewing exclusivity terms, look for:
Duration (30 days is reasonable, anything beyond 45 needs justification)
Performance benchmarks tied to exclusivity, like minimum qualified candidates per week
Early termination rights if the agency doesn't meet deliverables
Clear definition of what breaks exclusivity (can you accept inbound applications?)
The best approach: negotiate a trial period first. Give an agency 15 days exclusive to prove they can deliver, or consider alternatives to contingency recruiting. If they send quality candidates, extend it. If not, you haven't burned a month of hiring time.
Guarantee periods protect you if a hire doesn't work out. The most common guarantee period is 90 days, accounting for roughly half of recruitment agency guarantees. But what happens during that window varies wildly between contracts.
Three types of guarantees exist:
Full refund returns 100% of the fee back if the candidate leaves or is terminated within the guarantee period
Prorated refund returns a percentage based on how long the candidate stayed (60% if they leave at day 60)
Replacement-only means the agency finds another candidate instead of returning money
Replacement-only guarantees lock you into continuing with the same agency after an unsuccessful hire, which is why vetting external recruiters before signing is critical. Push for full money-back guarantees. If an agency resists, negotiate a hybrid: full refund in the first 30 days, prorated after.
Clause 3: Payment Terms and Fee Negotiation Points
Payment schedules matter as much as the percentage. Agency contracts request payment within 30 days of the candidate's start date, though terms vary by firm. Many agencies will consider net 60 or net 90 terms if you ask, particularly for repeat clients or multiple roles. This gives your new hire time to onboard before the bill comes due and aligns payment timing with your guarantee period.
The fee percentage itself is where you have real room to move. Start by asking for a volume discount if you're filling multiple roles, and understand different commission structures to negotiate better. Hiring three positions at once? Request 18% instead of 25%. Role difficulty should affect pricing too. A generic marketing coordinator isn't worth the same fee as a VP of Engineering requiring niche technical skills. Propose tiered pricing: 20% for senior roles, 15% for mid-level, 12% for junior positions. Market conditions give you influence as well. Hiring for remote roles with national candidate pools is easier than location-restricted searches, or you could work with fractional recruiters who offer more flexibility.
Clause 4: Candidate Ownership and Recruitment Period Windows
Candidate ownership clauses define how long an agency can claim a fee after introducing you to a candidate. Standard protection windows run 12 months, but some contracts push for longer.
Here's the scenario: you interview someone through Agency A in March. They're not the right fit. In November, that same person applies directly through your careers page. Agency A still claims the full fee because they "introduced" the candidate within their protection window.
Negotiate these specific terms:
Protection window of 6 months maximum instead of 12
Carve-outs for candidates who apply directly or through referrals after initial rejection
Clear definition of "introduction" requiring formal submission, on top of LinkedIn outreach
No fee if the candidate is hired for a different role than originally discussed
If an agency introduced someone for a sales role but you hire them 8 months later as a customer success manager, that's a different search. Learn when your startup needs recruiting help.
Clause 5: Termination Rights and Notice Periods
Termination clauses control your exit if the agency isn't delivering. Many contracts demand 30-90 days written notice with penalties for early termination, meaning you're stuck paying for months of inactivity.
Push for "termination for convenience" language that allows you to exit with 14 days notice instead of 90. If the agency hasn't placed anyone, you shouldn't owe fees.
Watch for clauses requiring payment for "work in progress" after termination. Some agencies claim fees for any candidate interviewed within 30 days of ending the agreement, regardless of when they're hired. Strike these provisions or limit the window to 7 days maximum for candidates already in final rounds.
How Dover's No Contracts Model Eliminates Traditional Fee Agreement Friction
Frequently Asked Questions
Final Thoughts on Recruitment Fee Agreements
Table of contents
