How to Build Your Startup Hiring Pipeline from Scratch
Dover
June 27, 2025
•
5 mins
Hiring for startups in 2025 is no joke; the competition is high. Executive hires take six months to fill on average, with early-stage companies facing challenges around:
Compensation expectations and budget constraints
Talent shortage vs the competition for skilled candidates
Remote work expanded the talent pool, but also increased competition
The traditional approach of posting a job when you need someone doesn't work anymore. By the time you realize you need a new hire, write the job description, and start interviewing, you're already months behind. This is where a proactive hiring pipeline becomes your competitive advantage. Instead of reactive hiring, you're creating a smarter approach that anticipates your hiring needs, helps you build relationships with potential candidates before you need them, and moves the pipeline quickly when the right opportunity comes up.
A hiring pipeline is an organized approach to identify, attract, and nurture potential candidates before you have open positions. Think of it as building relationships with talent you might want to hire in the future, rather than scrambling to find people when you desperately need them.
A strong hiring pipeline framework can reduce your time-to-hire. Instead of starting from zero when a position opens, you already have qualified candidates who know your company, understand your mission, and are interested in joining your team.
For startups, this approach fits well as the hiring needs are always changing. You might go months without hiring, then suddenly need to double your engineering team after a funding round. A hiring pipeline makes sure you're ready for both scenarios. Here's the reality that most startups face: only 30% of companies can fill a vacant role within 30 days, while 70% take up to four months.
Dover's free ATS, designed for startups, serves as the foundational tool for pipeline management. It centralizes all your candidate data, tracks interactions over time, and helps you keep relationships with potential hires even when you don't have immediate openings.
Now, let's help you build a hiring pipeline to suit your startup needs.
Building a successful hiring pipeline starts with understanding what roles you'll need 6-12 months from now. This isn't about crystal ball predictions, but about focusing on strategic planning based on your growth path and goals.
Start by mapping out your expected growth phases:
If you're planning to raise a Series A in 3 months, what roles will you need to fill with that funding?
If you're launching a new product, what skills will your team need that you don't currently have?
What kind of recruiting approach fulfills your hiring needs?
Consider both technical and non-technical roles in your planning. Many startups focus on engineering hires, but forget about the sales, marketing, and operations roles that become just as important as you scale. A balanced approach to pipeline building makes sure you're prepared for all types of hiring needs.
Create a simple roadmap that outlines:
Roles you'll definitely need in the next 6 months
Roles you'll likely need in the next 6-12 months
Skills that will become important as you scale
Leadership positions you'll need to fill as you grow
Dover's platform helps startups organize and plan their strategy with clear pipeline stages. Creating hiring rubrics for each anticipated role gives you consistency in your process and helps you find the right candidates.
Step 2: Set Up Your Recruiting Infrastructure
Your recruiting foundation makes pipeline management possible. Without the right tools and processes, even the best sourcing efforts will fall apart. A powerful applicant tracking system (ATS) can simplify talent pipeline management by centralizing candidate data, automating communication, and tracking key metrics. Dover's free ATS is built for startup needs. Dover's system takes a more balanced approach. It's not crazy complicated like those big enterprise tools, but it's also not some bare-bones solution that can't do what you need.
Dover brings together your entire hiring process into one place. From early candidate contact through final offer, everything is tracked and organized. This is important when you're maintaining relationships with candidates over months.
Infrastructure Component | Why It Matters | Dover Solution |
|---|---|---|
Centralized candidate database | Track interactions over time | Free ATS with unlimited storage (no hidden costs or feature limitations) |
Automated communication | Maintain regular touchpoints | Built-in email templates and scheduling |
Pipeline stage tracking | Monitor candidate progression | Customizable pipeline stages |
Team collaboration | Keep everyone aligned | Shared candidate profiles and notes |
Integrated sourcing tools | Reach more candidates faster | Free sourcing tool (post on 70+ job boards, capture emails, and ATS sync) |
Best practices suggest keeping your pipeline to 12 stages or less. Consistent processes will help keep your hiring team on track. Dover's platform follows this structure while remaining flexible.
Step 3: Build Your Candidate Sourcing Strategy
Successful candidate sourcing for startups calls for a multi-channel approach. You can't rely on job postings alone; the best candidates are often passive and need to be actively recruited.
Research shows that most startup hires come from friends, friends of friends, or ex-colleagues. This makes sense, good people know good people. Personal recommendations carry major weight in hiring choices.
Here's a complete sourcing strategy that works for startups:
Employee referrals: Your current team's network
Professional networking: Industry events, conferences, and meetups
Social media: LinkedIn, Twitter, and industry-specific platforms
Job board posting: Cast a wide net with strategic job postings
Direct outreach: Identifying and reaching out to passive candidates
University partnerships: Building relationships with relevant academic programs
Dover's integrated sourcing tools make this multi-channel approach simple. The free Chrome extension for LinkedIn can find candidate email contacts and send personalized outreach in no time.
Our platform's one-click job board posting allows you to post on 70+ job boards with a single submission. Instead of manually posting to Indeed, LinkedIn, AngelList, and dozens of other sites, you can send out your job posting everywhere at once.
Dover's employee referrals system lets you request referrals from your team, investors, or friends with zero setup. You can then track those referred candidates from introduction all the way through hire, giving you visibility into your most effective sourcing channels.
Step 4: Create Compelling Job Descriptions and Employer Branding
Your employer brand is what attracts candidates to your pipeline in the first place. Research shows that only 28% of HR professionals have an employer branding strategy, with 40% lacking a formal strategy entirely. This represents a huge chance for startups willing to invest in their employer reputation.
For early-stage companies, as you grow, your employees become your brand signal. The people you hire and how they talk about working at your company influence whether top candidates want to join your pipeline. This is why maintaining a positive company culture and employee experience is directly tied to your recruiting success.
Your job descriptions are often the first touchpoint candidates have. They need to be compelling, clear, and authentic.
Startup job descriptions should include:
Clear role expectations and growth opportunities
Honest assessment of the startup environment and challenges
Specific technical requirements and nice-to-haves
Company mission and values alignment
Compensation range and equity information
Remote work policies and team structure
Dover's job posting features help startups create professional, convincing job descriptions that reach the right candidates. We have templates and best practices designed for startup hiring needs. Read more about writing clear and compelling job descriptions to attract passive candidates.
Step 5: Implement a Candidate Screening and Evaluation Process
Step 6: Nurture Long-term Candidate Relationships
When to Scale: Using Fractional Recruiters for Pipeline Growth
FAQ
Conclusion: Building Your Hiring Pipeline with the Right Tools and Partners
Table of contents
